Catalonia and the Kabbalists

The Cota wedding eggplant with chard

I spent some time following in the footsteps of Kabbalists who lived in Catalonia, an area that straddles parts of the coastal and southern mountain areas of now Spain and France, and includes the beautiful, eclectic city of Barcelona. The strong sense of Catalan pride and identity and the excitement over the then- impending vote for independence from Spain was very much evident in my conversations with people, as were all of the “Si” graffiti and banners everywhere I visited.

In the backdrop of the current political situation, much of my time there was spent wandering  the slippery, winding stone streets of former Jewish ghettos in medieval towns to visit mikvahs and synagogues, trying to piece together what life was like for Jews who had a flourishing society there until their expulsion in 1492. The small city of Girona was the epicenter of Kabbalists and the home of Rabbi Moses ben Nachman (the Ramban) who eventually was the chief rabbi of Catalonia.

Jewish Museum, Girona

Of late, Spain has literally and figuratively uncovered its rich medieval Jewish history. Much seemingly by accident during construction, ancient tombstones, mikvahs and synagogues have been found. Doorposts with the markings of mezuzot are now proudly shown with placards. At the site of a mikvah in Girona is now the Jewish Museum, whose exhibits were partly an introduction to Judaism for tourists and a thorough examination of the Inquisition. Walking atop the city walls of Girona offered me a birds eye view into the physical manifestation of the Jewish ghetto, which was buttressed against the city’s massive imposing Catholic cathedral and the leading role it played in destroying the Jewish community.

During my time in Girona and Besalu (another spectacular medieval town that was 20-25% Jewish until they left the town in 1436, where I visited its 12th century mikvah that was found in 1964 and the adjacent synagogue discovered 10 year ago), I read the translation of “The Disputation of Barcelona” which was a public debate between the Ramban and a Jewish convert to Catholicism, Father Pablo Christiani, held in 1263 before King James of Aragon at the Royal Palace, about whether Jesus is the Messiah and questions about the legitimacy of Judaism. It is offensive and obnoxious, though at times I found myself cheering the Ramban for his brilliant, eloquent, clever responses. The Church claimed it won the debate and the Ramban left Aragon forever and moved to Jerusalem.


While Catalonia (or at least the tourism boards) now promotes and honors its  medieval Jewish history, it appears that  the country has done little (or perhaps nothing) to address its role in the Holocaust.

I traveled up from Girona along the spectacular Catalan coast to Portbou, the site of a memorial for the Jewish philosopher Walter Benjamin. Fleeing the Nazis, through a treacherous hike in the Pyrnees from France to Spain, he was arrested and placed in a Spanish prison, where he eventually killed himself. It is a powerful, somber monument on a seaside cliff overlooking the town, that appears to me like a rusted train car rammed into the ground at an angle, with a long narrow stairway inside that seemingly disappears into the sea water below.  What’s more remarkable about it, is that it’s the only Holocaust memorial in the  nation (and not even identified as such).

Ancient Jewish area of Barcelona

It was a conundrum because I could reflect upon the beautiful, rich Jewish community that had existed here and celebrate Shabbat (there are now tiny communities in both Barcelona and Girona), while simultaneously holding the devastating Spanish Jewish history.

At the Jewish Museum in Girona was a temporary exhibit about Jewish food, including a copy of the fascinating cooking/historical/anthropology book, A Drizzle of Honey: The Lives and Recipes of Spain’s Secret Jews by David M. Gitlitz and Linda Kay Davidson. Much of what the book’s authors learned about crypto-Jewish foods was ironically from Inquisition trial testimonies. While the food these Jews ate was often no different than their Arab or Christian neighbors, testimonies about people’s dietary habits were used to incriminate them (e.g. people preparing Shabbat stews, matzah, etc). The authors write, “based on the frequency of references specifically associating them with Iberian Jews, eggplant, greens like chard, and chickpeas . . . seem to have been defining characteristics of medieval Sephardic vegetable cuisine.”

The cookbook explains about the origins of recipe I chose, the Cota wedding eggplant with chard. The authors explain that in the late 15th century, “conversos were evidently so fond of eggplant that the satirical literature of the day is filled with pointed references to the predilection. Typical is the burlesque poem by Rodrigo Cota about a converso wedding at which the guests were served this vegetable.” The recipe is in the poem (see photo on the right). Furthermore, these “poetic jibes, later gathered into songbooks known as Cancioneros, often provide interesting anthropological data about contemporary customs, including Jewish cooking.”


The Cota Wedding Eggplant with Chard
I made a few slight adjustments to the recipe

1 medium eggplant
2 tablespoons salt
1 huge bunch of Swiss chard
2 tablespoons of olive oil
1/2 tsp saffron threads
1 medium onion, thinly sliced in quarters
2 1/2-3 cups water or vegetable broth
salt and white pepper to taste

Atop a city wall in Girona, with the city’s cathedral in the background.

1. Peel the eggplant and cut into 1/4 inch slices. Soak for 30 minutes in salted cold water (2 tbsp salt, 3 cups water). Rinse thoroughly and press out as much liquid as possible.
2. Wash the chard and cut the stalks into one inch pieces and the leaves, chopped (keep leaves and stalks separate).
3. Heat the olive oil and saffron in a large frying pan over low heat for about 5 minutes.
4. Add the onion and chard stalks and saute for about 10 minutes at medium-low heat. If they start to brown, add some broth or water to prevent sticking.
5. Add the eggplant slices. Add the water/broth and bring to a boil for 8 minutes. Lower the heat and simmer for about 15 minutes.
6. Add the chard (you might need to add some more broth or water to prevent sticking. Some excess liquid is good). Cook the chard for about 5 minutes.
7. Add salt and pepper to taste. Serve warm.



3 thoughts on “Catalonia and the Kabbalists

  1. Beautiful! I loved how you wove all those memories of our intense trip – dipping into different layers of history, and reflecting on the torn present. Looking forward to trying the recipe! Didn’t realize Eggplant was such a typical marano food 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Septimania and Turron | Neesh Noosh

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.